I believe the "meat and potatoes" of this topic are simple. Knowingly purchasing a recast, or recasting others work for profit or gain is wrong. To me there's no gray area there. I would also add that for me personally, to purchase an item (bio for example) for my own personal use, recast it for my own personal use (no selling or distributing) just so I can make multiple copies for myself, is something I would never do. I wouldn't feel right about it. I bought the piece from someone in good faith with the "unspoken" understanding that I wouldn't copy it for any reason. Again, that's just me. I could give a rats ass how anyone else feels about themselves laying in bed at night, but I have to feel good about me. I also don't want to be the guy that no one will sell to because "his actions are questionable". That's where I stand on things, but to each his own.